(after Hattaway and Jones)

Commander	number	% enemy men	% casualties	% enemy cas.	Efficiency Index	enemy Eff. Index
ATTACKS WON
Union*	6	163	11	78	84	165
Confederate*	3	108	23	105	132	239
Grant	6	141	8	91	94	121
Sherman	1	162	6	64	98	101
Lee	2	66	28	97	225	142
Jackson	4	105	14	49	281	143
ATTACKS LOST
Union*	9	140	12	166	68	124
Confederate*	8	88	31	128	187	179
Grant	6	165	16	229	70	264
Sherman	3	142	12	502	23	162
Lee	1	85	37	121	307	317
Jackson	1	47	16	137	121	78
DEFENSE WON
Union*	8	115	20	77	179	187
Confederate*	9	71	10	59	124	68
Grant	1	155	21	122	170	323
Sherman	5	85	9	46	187	73
Lee	9	61	13	51	271	85
Jackson	5	75	18	82	221	137
DEFENSE LOST
Union*	3	92	24	94	239	132
Confederate*	6	61	22	126	165	84
Grant	0	- -	- -	- -	- -	- -
Sherman	0	- -	- -	- -	- -	- -
Lee	1	55	15	70	223	46
Jackson	0	- -	- -	- -	- -	- -
ALL BATTLES
Union*	25	128	16	104	117	157
Confederate*	25	78	20	96	157	117
Grant	13	156	14	199	72	224
Sherman	9	106	9	77	120	98
Lee	13	64	18	68	266	116
Jackson	10	81	16	67	240	132
Lee's Performace in nine battles(from Hattaway & Jones p.729)
Lee win attack	1	104.7	21.6	130	102.6	- -
Lee lose attack	1	90	37.4	121.8	235.6	- -
Lee win defense	5	67.2	12.3	59.3	146.6	- -
Lee lose defense	2	67	23.5	115.4	192	- -
Lee all battles	9	75.6	19.7	92	158.4	- -

* = from Hattaway & Jones 26 battle data base

Source: Livermore's Numbers and Losses

M. Collie May 1993